Andrews Pitchforks combine

[chris_hkg]

Hi,
have noticed that Andrews pitchforks combine into one.

If you draw 2 Andrews forks, not every time, but often, they merge into one Andrews Pitchfork.

images included is an example of two forks, then changing the second fork to a modified schiff (can be any change), You then see they combine, one is a Modified Schiff and one standard. After OK and bringing up the drawing objects, you can see that it now listed twice.

Cheers
Chris

[NinjaTrader_PatrickH]

Hello chris_hkg,

Thank you for bringing this to our attention.

I am unable to reproduce, but as you said it does not always occur. I will continue to test this on my end.

[NinjaTrader_PatrickH]

Hello chris_hkg,

Thank you for your patience.

Please go to Help > About and advise what release you are using.

In addition, can you detail if this has occurred again on your installation?

[chris_hkg]

using beta 3, have done a re-install, need to test further, but hasn't happened again yet

[chris_hkg]

B4 issue remains with Pitchforks combine

Hi,
I have done more testing with B4,and the Andrews Pitchforks still combine after modifying second Pitchfork.
I now seem to be able to reproduce the error.

I'll use the ES as an example.
load any time frame say 5 min. Draw multiple Andrews Pitchforks (change the Calculation Method to either Schiff or Modified Schiff on the different Andrews Pitchforks. They all work as required.

Now change one of the Andrew Pitchforks to include additional levels (add say 25% and 75%) then SAVE template as Default

Delete all previous Andrew Pitchforks and redraw new ones. click on any pitchfork and change the calculation method, the problem should reoccur with the Andrews Pitchforks combine or one gets removed from the chart

Cheers
Chris

[NinjaTrader_PatrickH]

Hello chris_hkg,

Thank you for your update.

I am still unable to reproduce but I will continue to look into this further.

[NinjaTrader_PatrickH]

Hello chris_hkg,

We are able to reproduce this and development has received the report on this matter.