Issues PnF Charts

[soulfx]

Hello i restarted N8 and have pictures to send of the N8 PNF and N7 PNF.
You can see the differences in the volume.
Also the PNF bars are not the same - N8 is using tick replay.
I also took a picture of the Data Series used for each N8 and N7
What is the best approach to send in screenshots in this forum - to include a thumbnail or do i need to link it to Jing or similar
thanks

[soulfx]

Just an update on this ... i set break at EOD to true for the 3 reversal 1 box size 1 minute PNF and now at least todays bars resemble those on NT7 and the times on the NT8 are correct for today and prior days all bars are 22:00, then the very first session in chart has times.
Todays data though only plots bars from 9:13 est thus missing all the globex even though session template is CME globex index futures ETH.
So really until whatever is being fixed is fixed no reliable comparison can be made.
I just want to ensure i report the glitches i see so next beta we can have a stable reliable PNF that i can work with and compare with NT7. So there is not point sending the pictures
thanks

[soulfx]

Hello, the IsFirstBarOfSession and the tick replay and break at EOD and the times issues below relating to PNF charting and indicators seem to be resolved in the N8 beta v9.0
thanks

[soulfx]

In continuing use and testing of PNF - today i wanted to check and compare running the following :

1. A PNF chart box size 1 reversal 3 based on 1 minute closes - set tick replay to false
2. same as 1 except set tick replay to true

observe the difference in plots - is this expected - the purpose of setting tick replay to true is to capture the data that can be used in some indicators i have.

given the plot from 2 you can see it seems to break the PNF style with alternating x o columns -

Can you look at this on your end and compare

please let me know if you need further info to reproduce

thanks

[NinjaTrader_PaulH]

Hello soulfx,

Thanks for your post.

Following your directions I end up with two identical charts, one with tick replay, the other without. The X/O sequence appears the same across the charts.

Are you using RC2?

If so, can you post the two charts you are looking at?

[soulfx]

I am about to upgrade to RC2 in next few days - i noticed there was a small change to PNF for this release would this perhaps impact what i am seeing?
Once i have installed RC2 in next days i will recheck but the tick replay change i didnt see in the change log release notes comment
thanks

[NinjaTrader_PaulH]

Hello soulfx,

Thanks for your reply.

That would be the recommendation to update to RC2 and test there.

[soulfx]

Hello there installed RC2 and the PNF issue resolved. I had noticed this for some time but was too preoccupied with other issues lately. What was the error related to in that with tick replay set to true that the PNF bars did not appear correctly for prior releases; as this has been here prior to this release and i had submitted earlier issues with PNF and tick replay.
thanks

[NinjaTrader_PaulH]

Hello soulfx,

Thanks for your reply.

Glad you tested out and found no issues.

We would not have the specifics on what was resolved.

[NinjaTrader_Brett]

In our release notes fix likely related to issue #10346

http://ninjatrader.com/support/helpGuides/nt8/en-us/8_0_0_14.htm