VSA vs. Wyckoff Plugins

[StockJock]

I see that there are some indicator plugins available for NinjaTrader from both David Weis, who is an expert on the Wyckoff trading method, and from Tom Williams, who is an expert on Volume Spread Analysis. I'm wondering if anyone in this forum has tried these indicators and what your comments are about them. Click on the links below.

Wyckoff Market Analyzer

VSA Software Add-in

[NinjaTrader_AdamP]

StockJock,

Unfortunately I have not used these myself. I hope that the community can answer your questions. We are lucky to have such a great community of traders and developers.

Should you have any other questions, please don' t hesitate to contact us.

[mohi4u]

I see that there are some indicator plugins available for NinjaTrader from both David Weis, who is an expert on the Wyckoff trading method, and from Tom Williams, who is an expert on Volume Spread Analysis. I'm wondering if anyone in this forum has tried these indicators and what your comments are about them. Click on the links below.

Wyckoff Market Analyzer

VSA Software Add-in

Hello StockJock,

I tried both of the indicators and below is my feedback.
VSA Software Add-in for NinjaTrader is an excellent tool and a complete trading system
whereas
wyckoff-market-analyzer is just an additional (ninja) indicator, like several 3rd party indicators out there and is not a trading system.

Thanks & Regards,
Mohi

[seeseea]

Looking for VSA Ninja add-in

I see that there are some indicator plugins available for NinjaTrader from both David Weis, who is an expert on the Wyckoff trading method, and from Tom Williams, who is an expert on Volume Spread Analysis. I'm wondering if anyone in this forum has tried these indicators and what your comments are about them. Click on the links below.

Wyckoff Market Analyzer

VSA Software Add-in

The VSA software add-in link no longer exists. Does anyone have this module? I would really, really appreciate getting it. Thanks in advance.

[seeseea]

ATTENTION Mohi - Looking for the Ninja VSA modules

Hi - Could you send me or post these modules VSA add-in and Analyzer. I would really, really appreciate it. Thanks in advance!

[seeseea]

Hi Mohi with the VSA extensions.

Hello StockJock,

I tried both of the indicators and below is my feedback.
VSA Software Add-in for NinjaTrader is an excellent tool and a complete trading system
whereas
wyckoff-market-analyzer is just an additional (ninja) indicator, like several 3rd party indicators out there and is not a trading system.

Thanks & Regards,
Mohi

Hi Mohi - Could you send me or post these modules VSA add-in and Analyzer. I would really, really appreciate it.

I have searched all over the Ninja site and have not found them. the Ninja peiople say that that server is no longer available. But maybe you have them?

Thanks in advance!

[NinjaTrader_PatrickG]

If you can't find what you're looking for here on the forums, I encourage you to write into PlatformSupport[AT]NinjaTrader[DOT]com with a brief description of what you're searching for. We will then put you in contact with our Business Development Team which manages the relationship between our users and the third-party developers who may have or could make the add--on you seek.

[seeseea]

If you can't find what you're looking for here on the forums, I encourage you to write into PlatformSupport[AT]NinjaTrader[DOT]com with a brief description of what you're searching for. We will then put you in contact with our Business Development Team which manages the relationship between our users and the third-party developers who may have or could make the add--on you seek.

Thanks Patrick. Yes, I know there are firms and engineers out there who can build stuff, but I want to actually get the VSA code that was offered freely here so I can integrate it with what I am currently building myself.

It WAS here and WAS offered. It must still be around somewhere unless some developer thought it conflicted with what they were selling.

I am still looking, but thanks anyway.